Talk:canSAS-2012: Difference between revisions
From canSAS
| (5 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
---- | |||
== 2012-07-28 Notes of Discussions == | == 2012-07-28 Notes of Discussions == | ||
=== Data storage formats === | === Data storage formats === | ||
see: [[2012_Data_Discussion]] | see: [[2012_Data_Discussion]] and [[User:Boesecke | discussion from Peter Boesecke]] | ||
* sasCIF | * sasCIF | ||
| Line 10: | Line 12: | ||
* IUCr Diffraction Data Deposition Working Group proposal, SAS Commission response to proposal, & whether proposal would impact SAS data standardization | * IUCr Diffraction Data Deposition Working Group proposal, SAS Commission response to proposal, & whether proposal would impact SAS data standardization | ||
* discussed use of standard formats to ensure some level of integrity in publications | * discussed use of standard formats to ensure some level of integrity in publications | ||
---- | |||
==== Considerations for the design of a canSAS-multid format ==== | ==== Considerations for the design of a canSAS-multid format ==== | ||
| Line 26: | Line 30: | ||
* well-defined? | * well-defined? | ||
* ensure it gets used! | * ensure it gets used! | ||
---- | |||
=== NeXus main page === | === NeXus main page === | ||
see: http://www.nexusformat.org | |||
* How to find links to [http://download.nexusformat.org/doc/html/ClassDefinitions-Application.html Definitions] and [http://download.nexusformat.org/doc/html/Examples.html Examples]? Make better [http://www.nexusformat.org/ main page] links. | * How to find links to [http://download.nexusformat.org/doc/html/ClassDefinitions-Application.html Definitions] and [http://download.nexusformat.org/doc/html/Examples.html Examples]? Make better [http://www.nexusformat.org/ main page] links. | ||
** NAPI examples don't work (Ron Ghosh). What is the problem? Fix? | ** NAPI examples don't work (Ron Ghosh). What is the problem? Fix? | ||
| Line 33: | Line 42: | ||
* [http://download.nexusformat.org/doc/html/ClassDefinitions-Application.html#NXsas NXsas]: a definition for raw SAS data | * [http://download.nexusformat.org/doc/html/ClassDefinitions-Application.html#NXsas NXsas]: a definition for raw SAS data | ||
* [http://download.nexusformat.org/doc/html/ClassDefinitions-Application.html#NXiqproc NXiqproc]: general definition, might work for reduced SAS or at least be considered a starting point | * [http://download.nexusformat.org/doc/html/ClassDefinitions-Application.html#NXiqproc NXiqproc]: general definition, might work for reduced SAS or at least be considered a starting point | ||
---- | |||
=== IUCr World Database of Crystallographers === | === IUCr World Database of Crystallographers === | ||
http://www.iucr.org/people/wdc | |||
* Is this list contemporary? | * Is this list contemporary? | ||
* Who are the consumers of this information? | |||
* Are standard terms codified? | |||
* Search for "small-angle" or "small angle" is not as useful as "SAXS" or "SANS" | |||
* SAS does not consider itself under "Crystallography" | |||
---- | |||
=== SAS Portal === | === SAS Portal === | ||
| Line 53: | Line 69: | ||
* What role should canSAS take? | * What role should canSAS take? | ||
* What do we recommend the IUCr provide through the [http://www.iucr.org/iucr/commissions/small-angle-scattering IUCr/CSAS] web site? | * What do we recommend the IUCr provide through the [http://www.iucr.org/iucr/commissions/small-angle-scattering IUCr/CSAS] web site? | ||
---- | |||
=== PDB data deposition task force === | === PDB data deposition task force === | ||
Latest revision as of 13:27, 28 July 2012
2012-07-28 Notes of Discussions
Data storage formats
see: 2012_Data_Discussion and discussion from Peter Boesecke
- sasCIF
- newer standard for publishing bio SAXS data in IUCr journals (doesn't specify format, but includes data validation)
- canSAS1d
- NeXus
- IUCr Diffraction Data Deposition Working Group proposal, SAS Commission response to proposal, & whether proposal would impact SAS data standardization
- discussed use of standard formats to ensure some level of integrity in publications
Considerations for the design of a canSAS-multid format
- What is the definition of reduced SAS data?
- purpose of the format?
- ease of use?
- ease of maintainability?
- user support?
- what content?
- can it handle 'big data'?
- can it cope with sparse data?
- build in coordinate specifications
- Compatibility with multiple techniques:
- SAXS+WAXS, ASAXS, GISAXS, SAXS(t), XPCS, ...
- extensibility?
- well-defined?
- ensure it gets used!
NeXus main page
see: http://www.nexusformat.org
- How to find links to Definitions and Examples? Make better main page links.
- NAPI examples don't work (Ron Ghosh). What is the problem? Fix?
- Needs more help oriented for data consumers
- NXsas: a definition for raw SAS data
- NXiqproc: general definition, might work for reduced SAS or at least be considered a starting point
IUCr World Database of Crystallographers
http://www.iucr.org/people/wdc
- Is this list contemporary?
- Who are the consumers of this information?
- Are standard terms codified?
- Search for "small-angle" or "small angle" is not as useful as "SAXS" or "SANS"
- SAS does not consider itself under "Crystallography"
SAS Portal
- There can be only one!
- Considerations for the design of a portal
- who is the target audience?
- should it support languages other than English?
- should it just be links to existing content or 'more dynamic', perhaps with a 'SAS news' section, recent results, etc?
- include an FAQ?
- incorporate social media?
- should it 'involve' the IUCr SAS Commission?
- how should it be promoted to the SAS community?
- What role should canSAS take?
- What do we recommend the IUCr provide through the IUCr/CSAS web site?
PDB data deposition task force
(Information from email chat with Jill Trewhella)
Task force remit: Bio-molecular Small-Angle Scattering Data and Interpretation; Data Deposition and Model Archiving
Task Force Membership: Helen Berman, Wayne Hendrickson, Gerard Kleywegt, Guy Montelione, Mamuro Sato, Torsten Schwede, Dmitri Svergun, John Tainer, Jill Trewhella
Preliminary Recommendations:
- Need a standard dictionary for definitions of terms for data collection and for managing a data repository. X-rays and neutrons.
- Need a data repository that holds standard data set, is searchable, internationally accessible for download.
- Bead and atomistic models based on SAS data should be archived in a searchable data base and (given that the underlying data are not atomic resolution) there be specific information in regard to the quality/reliability/uniqueness of the result. Criteria for these assessments need to be defined; issues chi squared, error propagation, sensible stereo-chemistry requirement is argued and needs yet to be agreed.
- Need a meeting of key people from different task forces to come together to define what the pdb should be archiving.
We also discussed what might be in the PDB and what might be in a parallel "hybrid model" data base that is distinct from the PDB, but with a common interface. By this means it would be easy to communicate that the hybrid models are not based purely on data that can provide atomistic (or something close to it) information.
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS:
- While a database of data is desirable from the PDB perspective, it is not clear who should be the steward
- Data should include information about sample and its history/preparation etc., and treatment of background (and potentially storing background data as well)
- A lunchtime session has been scheduled at SAS 2012 (Sydney, November) to discuss these standards with the community
- Ideas from Acta Cryst. D, 68, 620–626 (2012) are embodied in this
